When Valve launched the Steam Deck in 2022, few expected it to become a benchmark for portable gaming. The device surprised critics and gamers alike by delivering a remarkably smooth gaming experience, despite its modest hardware specifications. Its success did not go unnoticed. Soon, major players like Asus, Lenovo, and MSI entered the market with their own handheld consoles, boasting significantly more powerful components. The Asus ROG Ally, Lenovo Legion Go, and MSI Claw all promised higher graphics settings, better frame rates, and an overall superior experience to the Steam Deck. Yet, as real-world usage and new testing have revealed, these devices have largely failed to live up to that promise. The culprit is not the hardware, but the software—specifically, the operating system.
Recent benchmark tests conducted by Ars Technica have shed light on a surprising performance gap. The publication compared two identical Lenovo Legion Go S units, one running Windows 11 and the other running Valve’s SteamOS. The results were striking. Across multiple high-end games, the SteamOS-equipped device consistently outperformed its Windows counterpart, even when both ran the same resolution and graphics settings. In some cases, the performance difference was dramatic. For example, the demanding game Returnal managed only 18 frames per second (FPS) on Windows 11, but soared to 33 FPS when the same hardware ran SteamOS—an 83 percent improvement. Even after the Legion Go’s Windows installation was tweaked with Asus drivers (which performed better than Lenovo’s own drivers), SteamOS still came out ahead in every test.
Why does SteamOS deliver such a decisive advantage? The answer lies in Valve’s long-term, focused development philosophy. Unlike Microsoft, which designs Windows as a general-purpose operating system for everything from spreadsheets to video editing, Valve has spent years refining SteamOS specifically for gaming. The system is lean, stripped of unnecessary background processes, services, and “bloatware” that often accumulate on Windows-based handhelds. When manufacturers like Asus or Lenovo ship a device with Windows 11, they typically add their own customization layers, driver suites, and utility software. While well-intentioned, these additions often consume system resources, introduce latency, and conflict with game performance. SteamOS, by contrast, is a lightweight, dedicated gaming environment that minimizes overhead and lets the hardware focus on what matters: running games smoothly.
This finding presents a clear fork in the road for companies hoping to compete with the Steam Deck. One option, already demonstrated by Lenovo with its Legion Go S, is to officially allow or even encourage the installation of SteamOS. By offering users a choice between operating systems, manufacturers can let their hardware shine without being held back by Windows inefficiencies. The other option is to develop a superior alternative—a task that is far easier said than done.
Microsoft and Asus are betting on this second path. In early June, the two companies unveiled a collaborative device tentatively called the ROG Xbox Ally X. Microsoft’s stated goal is to create an Xbox-like experience on a handheld PC, matching the performance of the Steam Deck while leveraging the vast Xbox ecosystem. If recent updates to the Xbox PC app are any indication, the new device will support not only Xbox games but also titles from other platforms such as Steam and Battle.net. This is a key advantage, as SteamOS does not officially support non-Steam storefronts out of the box (though workarounds exist through tools like Lutris or Heroic Games Launcher). A handheld that can natively play more games—and run them better than the Steam Deck—could indeed dethrone Valve’s device.
However, the bar is high. Valve has proven that optimising an operating system for a specific hardware profile yields tangible benefits. Microsoft’s challenge is to reinvent Windows—or a variant of it—to be equally streamlined without sacrificing its versatility. The company has a mixed track record here; previous attempts to create lightweight Windows versions for tablets and netbooks often ended in compromise. Meanwhile, Asus will need to ensure that its hardware drivers and software layers complement rather than hinder performance.
Until such a device arrives, the Steam Deck remains the king of portable PC gaming—not because of raw specs, but because of a carefully tuned operating system that punches above its weight. And while the rumoured Steam Deck 2 will inevitably raise the bar further, the current generation has already taught the industry a valuable lesson: great gaming is not just about what’s inside the box, but how the box thinks. For now, SteamOS is the smartest operating system in the room.